22 Delightfully Decadent Recipes for Fat Tuesday (2024)

Even if you can’t make it to New Orleans for a classic Carnival celebration, that doesn’t mean you should forgo the fun. Bring the party home on Fat Tuesday with these 22 decadent sweet and savory eats. Let’s just say there’s nothing light about these delightful recipes, but there’s nothing wrong with indulging on the ULTIMATE cheat day, right? Of course, if you’re looking for healthy hacks we sure do have you covered elsewhere!

1. Classic Fried Italian Pizza: Rounds of dough are first fried in hot oil until puffy before getting slathered with sauce and cheese. All of that is followed by a blitz in a hot oven until the whole shebang is bubbly, melty and downright irresistible. As if pizza wasn’t awesome enough already… (via Half Baked Harvest)

2. Spicy Sofritas Veggie Bowls (Vegetarian): Smothered in smokey chipotle sauce, tofu is transformed into a crave-worthy meat replacement for your next burrito bowl. Our forks are ready to dig right in. (via Pinch of Yum)

3. Slow Cooker Loaded Baked Potato Soup: Loaded with cream, cheese and all of the usual baked potato toppings, a bowlful of this soup is sure to take the chill right out of your bones. Enjoy it beyond Fat Tuesday as part of your next snow day or après ski menu. (via Malibu Kitchen)

4. The Double Cheese Poutine Burger: Loaded fries may just be one trend we overlooked for 2015. If this burger is any evidence, sides of unadorned fries are sooo last year. (via Food and Wine)

5. Prosciutto and Goat Cheese Strata: Enjoy this savory bread pudding for breakfast or as a midnight snack; it’s a surefire way to begin or end your day on a high note. (via Food52)

7. Black and Blue Mac and Cheese: Guinness (or your fave dark brew), cheddar and blue cheese team up to create a rich, velvety sauce for this homemade mac and cheese. Don’t be surprised if it makes an encore appearance on St. Patrick’s Day. (via Life as a Strawberry)

8. Muffaletta Sandwich: When it comes to sandwiches, if you love a one-to-one ratio of cold cuts and cheese to bread, the muffaletta has your name written all over it. Even better, it’s a terrific make-ahead meal — the longer it sits soaking up all the flavors of tapenade and salami, the better it gets. (via HonestlyYUM)

9. Maple-Brined Smoked Fried Chicken: Brined, smoked and then fried? A whole lot of love goes into each piece of this juicy chicken. Serve it up à la carte or atop a savory waffle. (via Chocolate and Marrow)

10. Cajun Chicken Alfredo Casserole: Brace yourself: There’s an entire quart of heavy cream and nearly as much cheese in this luscious pasta bake. (via The Lazy Mom’s Cooking Blog)

11. Big Easy Eggs Benedict: You don’t need to fuss with making hollandaise for this eggs Benny. Instead, an easy remoulade spiked with Cajun seasoning and hot sauce is spooned over the stack of crab cakes, fried green tomatoes and a runny-yolk egg. (via Amy in the Kitchen)

12. Fried Bowtie Pasta: Set out bowlfuls of these crispy snacks for folks to nibble on while they sip their Mardi Gras co*cktails. (via ZagLeft)

Sweet Indulgences

13. Ice Cream Sundae Cups: Why choose between ice cream and cookies when you can enjoy the best of both worlds in a few bites? (via Brit + Co)

14. King Cake Fries: Cinnamon-sugar sweet potato fries make for a delightful dessert when drizzled with brown butter cream cheese glaze and praline sauce. Chopped pecans and a generous shake of colorful sprinkles finish things off quite nicely. (via Glazed and Confused)

15. Bourbon and Butterscotch Pudding With Assorted Toppings: These grown-up pudding cups topped with a plume of whipped cream, crumbled bacon and graham crackers definitely deserve an invite to your Fat Tuesday celebration. (via Chocolate and Marrow)

16. Momof*cku Milk Bar Chocolate Chip Cake: This Momof*cku original features four alternating homemade elements layered sky-high, so you’ll want to start making all the pieces several days ahead of time. Trust that your effort will be rewarded BIG time. (via Hummingbird High)

17. Fritos No-Bake Bars With Bacon and Red Pepper Flakes: So wrong, yet so right. These sweet, salty and ever-so-slightly spicy no-bake bars are chock-full of peanut butter, caramel and bacon action. (via Jule’s Food…)

18. Salted Chocolate Chunk Cookie Layer Cake: A touch of flaky sea salt takes this chocolate chip cookie and liqueur-enhanced ganache creation to new heights. (via Butter and Brioche)

19. Peanut Butter Chocolate Tart (Gluten-Free, Vegan): Creamy peanut butter filling and a thick layer of dark chocolate and coconut milk ganache are a delightful combo, as always, atop a nutty, almond flour crust. (via From Jessica’s Kitchen)

20. Chocolate Pecan Cookies: Whether you whip up a batch of these molten-centered cookies or any of Dominique Ansel’s other indulgent inventions, you cannot go wrong. (via Food Network)

21. Salted Caramel Croquembouche Cake: You could stop at just the salted caramel mud cake or choux pastry topper for a celebration-worthy dessert. But when combined, they are sure to elicit many more oohs and ahhs from anyone who catches a glimpse. (via Butter and Brioche)

22. Salted Caramel Lava Cakes for Two (Vegan): You just may be tempted to make these gooey-centered cakes for two a recipe for one; they’re undoubtedly hard to resist. (via Veggiethe Beast)

Which of these decadent recipes is worth a splurge? Share your faves, along with any indulgent creations you’ve come up with below!

Heather Sage

Heather Sage is a gluten-free recipe developer and freelance writer living in Orlando by way of the Silicon Valley. When she isn’t playing around with alternative flours in the kitchen, she can be found tackling DIY projects around the house or exploring her neighborhood. Check out her gluten-free recipe blog, A Sage Amalgam.

22 Delightfully Decadent Recipes for Fat Tuesday (2024)

FAQs

What is the most popular food on Fat Tuesday? ›

What are some foods traditionally eaten on Fat Tuesday? Depending on your tradition, religion, or culture, people enjoy a variety of foods on Fat Tuesday, including pancakes, king cake, jambalaya, or a crawfish boil. Individuals consume foods high in fat and sugar to prepare for Lenten fasting.

What do you bring to a Fat Tuesday party? ›

Just what should you serve for Fat Tuesday? Perhaps fried shrimp in a Po'Boy sandwich, or shrimp and rice cooked with andouille sausage, similar to how they do in Cajun country. A pot of gumbo packed with shrimp and crab is a good one-and-done, make-ahead dish; the rich flavors develop if you cook it the day before.

What can you not eat on Fat Tuesday? ›

There are fasting guidelines on Ash Wednesday and throughout Lent, but Fat Tuesday generally does not have restrictions on what to eat.

What does everyone eat on Fat Tuesday? ›

25 Fat Tuesday Recipes for Your Mardi Gras Menu
  • King Cake. "I'm from New Orleans and have had pretty much every bakery's king cake. ...
  • Seafood Gumbo. ...
  • Green Onion Blinis with Red Pepper Relish & Goat Cheese. ...
  • Slow-Cooker Jambalaya. ...
  • Brazilian Cheese Puffs. ...
  • Sweet Tortelli. ...
  • English Pancakes. ...
  • Bahian Fish Stew.

What pastry do you eat on Fat Tuesday? ›

This day is celebrated by indulging in the traditional Polish jelly-filled pastry known as a pączek (PON-check). The more commonly used name for these is pączki (POONCH-kee), which is the plural pronunciation for this sweet treat. Pączki are made from richer yeast dough that won't collapse when you bite into it.

What is the Fat Tuesday king cake? ›

King Cake is a frosted seasonal treat usually eaten between January 6, known as King's Day or Twelfth Night, and Fat Tuesday. The name King Cake is derived from the Three Wise Men in the Bible, who came bearing gifts for the newborn Jesus on the Twelfth Night.

What is a Fat Tuesday drink? ›

Malibu Rum + 151 Rum + Piña Colada.

What is the traditional Catholic Fat Tuesday meal? ›

Traditionally, pancakes were eaten in abundance on Fat Tuesday so that the kitchens could be cleared of all butter, eggs, and milk since these were not eaten during Lent.

What do Catholics eat for Fat Tuesday? ›

Traditional Fat Tuesday Meals

Many celebrations include donuts, pancakes, and Polish Pączki. One popular favorite food item is Mardi Gras King Cake—a delicious cake with a small plastic baby hidden inside, representing the baby Jesus.

What is traditional Fat Tuesday breakfast? ›

Pancakes

The original idea was to bung all the fat, milk and eggs you had left in the house into one mega-batch of pancake mix on Shrove Tuesday, to use up any animal products before Easter.

What do Christians eat on Fat Tuesday? ›

Many Christian congregations thus observe the day through eating pancakes or, more specifically, the holding of pancake breakfasts, as well as the ringing of church bells to remind people to repent of their sins before the start of Lent.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 6290

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.